Violence, not just violent patterns

Violence, not just violent patterns

Seven o'clock in the evening, on the screen, a phone call from the “Hadar” detention center. Uri is on the line, asking for advice.

“Hello, an indictment was filed against me because I raised my hand on my wife, but I didn't mean to.” The next day, his mother contacted me and handed me the indictment.

From reading and studying the indictment, I got the impression that this is an angry person, an angry person, I could feel the frustration through the words describing the events.

A claim that he slapped his wife was not attributed to Uri. The indictment also did not attribute to him that he punched her or, God forbid, used an object to hit her. The indictment told about a man who attacked the other party in an ugly way, these were “frustration” attacks.

What are “frustration” attacks? There isn't really a definition for it, it is an insight that builds up over the years, experience. But if we try to distill or paint, these are assaults which apparently can point to a person who is “stomping his feet”, really a stored anger that does not give rest to the offending party when for him, the way to vent his frustration is, assault.

In fact, the indictment recounts two specific incidents: in the first incident, during an argument between the couple, Uri “gathered” his wife's mouth to pieces as he claims, he did so so that she could not scream and in the process, caused damage to her mouth.

In the second incident, Uri pushed his wife towards the wall, prevented her from leaving the house by locking the door and scattered her clothes on the floor while shouting and threatening her.

Sounds very bad, no one would want to be in her place.

I met Uri in the detention center. A young man, 27 years old, a construction engineer who unfolds the mask of his life in a technical way. Uri grew up in a loving and warm normative family, a functional and supportive family. However, as we delved into the circumstances of his life, Uri “opened up” and said that as a child, when he was 9 years old, he stayed on Passover Eve, in the area of ​​the attack at the “Park” hotel in Netanya. To remind you, many Israelis were killed there. According to him, he experienced over the years and to this day, the 'booms', the screams, the flashes of light and the smells from that event.

We progressed in conversation, and to my question, where he served and what he did in his military service, Uri replied that he was a fighter in the “Nut” patrol. As we delved deeper, Uri shared that during his military service, he encountered terrorists and these encounters caused him many difficulties, painful memories.

We asked the honorable court for a review, so that we can get a picture of the situation examining his mental state and degree of dangerousness.

The probation service, the body entrusted with his diagnosis on behalf of the State of Israel, met Uri within the prison walls and after a thorough examination, recommended his release to house arrest. After intensive discussions, the recommendation was adopted by the court.

During the management of the case I requested that Uri undergo a comprehensive diagnosis and indeed, after a period of significant treatment under the auspices of the probation service, psychological treatment that Uri requested for himself in order to find out how things escalated to the point of harming another, it was found that Uri suffers from post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) ) which has not been addressed or processed since the days of the Park Hotel attack. It was also determined that Uri does not have violent patterns.

I asked, how is it possible that Uri was found not to have violent patterns? After all, he beat his wife. The complainant in the story does not bear responsibility for Uri's mental state, she certainly should not have been harmed either mentally or physically, however, this is indeed the diagnosis.
At the end of things, Uri took full responsibility for his actions in front of his wife, expressed deep regret and asked not to conduct evidence. It should be noted that later, the couple separated.

During the management of the case, we made sure to include Uri in several treatment groups in which he processed the post-trauma he suffered. He was even treated at “Beit Noam” – which provides treatment for battered men.

Uri today, leads a normal and normative lifestyle, punishes sin, is diagnosed and treated.

Correct escort, saves lives.
Isabel Fox, criminal attorney – https://www.ifvlaw.co.il

O"d Isabel Fox
Photography: Zohar Kaminsky

Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Enable Notifications OK No thanks